English  |  正體中文  |  简体中文  |  全文筆數/總筆數 : 48329/52207 (93%)
造訪人次 : 52937405      線上人數 : 3935
RC Version 6.0 © Powered By DSPACE, MIT. Enhanced by NTU Library IR team.
搜尋範圍 查詢小技巧:
  • 您可在西文檢索詞彙前後加上"雙引號",以獲取較精準的檢索結果
  • 若欲以作者姓名搜尋,建議至進階搜尋限定作者欄位,可獲得較完整資料
  • 進階搜尋
    主頁 ‧ 登入 ‧ 上傳 ‧ 說明 ‧ 關於CCUR ‧ 管理 到手機版


    請使用永久網址來引用或連結此文件: https://irlib.pccu.edu.tw/handle/987654321/54842


    題名: 僱用人受領遲延之法律問題與實務趨勢探討
    Legal Issues and Practical Trends in the Employer’s Delay in Acceptance
    作者: 江靜怡
    CHIANG, CHING-YI
    貢獻者: 法律學系
    關鍵詞: 僱用人受領遲延
    民法第487條
    違法解僱
    工資請求權
    日本民法第536條
    休業津貼
    Employer's Delay in Acceptance
    Article 487 of the Civil Code
    Wrongful Dismissal
    Wage Claims
    Article 536 of the Japanese Civil Code
    Leave Allowance
    日期: 2026
    上傳時間: 2026-04-17 11:15:41 (UTC+8)
    摘要: 民法第487條規定僱用人受領勞務遲延時,受僱人無補服勞務之義務,仍得請求報酬。此規定攸關違法解僱情境下勞工之工資請求權,然實務對於僱用人何時構成受領遲延,長期存有見解分歧。本文以民國109年至113年間最高法院、臺灣高等法院及臺北、新北、士林地方法院之相關判決為研究對象,透過量化統計與質性分析,系統性探討我國實務就僱用人受領遲延認定標準之發展趨勢。依據判決分析,實務見解可歸納為三種類型:最寬鬆說認為雇主違法解僱時點即構成受領遲延,勞工無須另為給付提出;折衷說主張勞工應以提出異議、申請調解或起訴等方式表達繼續提供勞務之意願,始認定雇主受領遲延;最嚴格說則要求勞工須有具體準備給付勞務之行為,始令雇主負受領遲延責任。研究結果顯示,折衷說為目前實務主流見解,占半數以上判決採納;最寬鬆說則呈逐年遞減趨勢;最嚴格說僅見於特定案件類型,適用比例最低。此一分布反映司法實務在勞工保護、訴訟經濟及民法體系一致性之間,傾向採取折衷說所代表之平衡立場。在現行法制下,折衷說提供相對明確之判斷標準,並於受領遲延起算時點上多回溯至違法解僱之日,實質上兼顧法理一致性與勞工權益保護,為目前最適合我國司法實務之認定標準。
    透過比較法研究,分析日本民法第536條第2項危險負擔規定與日本勞動基準法第26條休業津貼制度之雙層保障體系。日本法將經營管理上之障礙納入雇主歸責事由,並輔以雇用調整助成金之財政支援機制,為勞工提供平均工資百分之六十之最低保障。此種制度設計固值借鏡,惟我國若欲引進類似規範,須審慎評估資金來源、最低給付門檻及防弊機制等配套問題,始能兼顧勞工保障與企業永續經營之雙重目標。

    Article 487 of the Taiwan Civil Code provides that when an employer delays in accepting labor services, the employee is not obligated to perform supplementary services and may still claim remuneration. This provision is crucial for protecting workers' wage claims in cases of wrongful dismissal. However, judicial practice has long diverged on the criteria for determining when an employer constitutes delay in acceptance.
    This study examines judgments rendered by the Supreme Court, Taiwan High Court, and the Taipei, New Taipei, and Shilin District Courts from 2020 to 2024, employing both quantitative and qualitative analysis to systematically explore the development trends in judicial standards for determining employer's delay in acceptance. Based on the analysis, judicial opinions can be categorized into three approaches: the most lenient standard holds that wrongful dismissal itself constitutes delay in acceptance without requiring the employee to tender performance; the compromise approach requires employees to express their willingness to continue providing services through objections, mediation applications, or litigation; and the strictest standard demands concrete preparatory acts for performance before holding employers liable for delay in acceptance.
    The findings reveal that the compromise approach represents the mainstream judicial opinion, adopted in more than half of the judgments examined. The most lenient standard shows a declining trend year by year, while the strictest standard appears only in specific case types with the lowest application rate. This distribution reflects that judicial practice tends toward the balanced position represented by the compromise approach, mediating among worker protection, judicial economy, and civil law systematic coherence. Under the current legal framework, the compromise approach provides relatively clear adjudication standards and, by retroactively calculating the commencement of delay in acceptance to the date of wrongful dismissal in most cases, effectively balances legal consistency with worker rights protection, representing the most appropriate standard for Taiwan's current judicial practice.
    Through comparative legal research, this study analyzes Japan's dual protection system comprising Article 536, Paragraph 2 of the Japanese Civil Code regarding risk allocation and Article 26 of the Japanese Labor Standards Act establishing the leave allowance system. Japanese law incorporates managerial and operational obstacles into employer liability and provides a minimum guarantee of sixty percent of average wages, supported by the Employment Adjustment Subsidy system. While this institutional design merits consideration, Taiwan must carefully evaluate supporting mechanisms including funding sources, minimum payment thresholds, and fraud prevention measures before introducing similar regulations, to balance both worker protection and sustainable business operations.
    顯示於類別:[法律學系暨法律學研究所] 博碩士論文

    文件中的檔案:

    檔案 描述 大小格式瀏覽次數
    index.html0KbHTML255檢視/開啟


    在CCUR中所有的資料項目都受到原著作權保護.


    DSpace Software Copyright © 2002-2004  MIT &  Hewlett-Packard  /   Enhanced by   NTU Library IR team Copyright ©   - 回饋